Land VS Diary - the poll...

[MinionZombie]

Tongue-in-cheek, yes ... but information that'd be interesting to have. Quite simple, and purely about Land of the Dead, and Diary of the Dead. But please - let's not make this yet another Land Lovers VS Haters thread, or same for Diary. Instead, a pure and simple comparison between the two exclusively, ignoring the other films in GAR's zombie canon, as well as zed flicks in general. A simple 3-tier system for each film - either "YAY!", "meh...", or "BOO!" - and all the possible combinations between the two films. VOTE NOW!

[MikePizzoff]

Land - meh Diary - BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!

[Mike70]

i've said it many times: i like both land and diary, despite their flaws. land yay (with qualification) and diary yay (with qualification).

[bassman]

Land - Yay Diary - meh I think Land has gotten better with more viewings, but Diary seems to be going in the opposite direction. I liked it at first, but I'm disliking it more and more every time I see it.

[MinionZombie]

Ooh, you fast buggers - well, the poll is now there - so VOTE now, good people of HPOTD! I've added the votes manually for the two Mikes...don't you worry about it. My vote is for Land YAY!, Diary meh...

[axlish]

I'll take it a step (or four) further... Night 68 YAY! Dawn YAY! Day Boo! Night 90 Boo! Land Boo! Diary Yay! And if I haven't pissed anyone off yet... Return YAY! Dawn 04 YAY!

[Mike70]

I'll take it a step (or four) further... Night 68 YAY! Dawn YAY! Day Boo! Night 90 Boo! Land Boo! Diary Yay! And if I haven't pissed anyone off yet... Return YAY! Dawn 04 YAY! there's always got to be a rebel in the mix. and dude, that avatar freaks me the fook out for some reason i can't quite put my finger on.

[MinionZombie]

there's always got to be a rebel in the mix. and dude, that avatar freaks me the fook out for some reason i can't quite put my finger on. Always gotta be somebody going against the grain...in two instances here... *fetches the paddle ... fer some paddlin'*

[axlish]

[Bub666]

Land - Yay Diary - Yay

[clanglee]

Meh on Both. But they do waver a bit on the Boo side from time to time. Depending on how much attention I am paying to the movie.

[Trin]

Land - meh Diary - Boo I have to say, one widely expressed HPOTD prediction came out to be true. I like Land more now than I did when it first came out. However, that is only because Diary lowered the freaking curve to the point Land looks better compared to its Dead peers than it used to. Maybe GAR is only making movies these days to further point out how great his movies USED to be. Cagey GAR. Very cagey!!

[3pidemiC]

Land - Yay Diary - Meh

[RustyHicks]

Land-meh Diary- Boo Was disappointed with the last two, maybe the 3rd will be a charmer

[Andy]

Ya'argggghhhhh ye scurvy land lubbers