World War Z movie

[EvilNed]

Compared to the book however, it was a shiny new turd. No, compared to the book it is a disc, or VHS casette, whereas the book is a book.

[Trin]

I agree, it was a shallow parody of the statements in the book. When I saw the movie, it didn't feel like the makers of the movie were trying to make different political statements. It felt like they they totally missed what the book was saying. I agree. And you said it well. The movie had characters state some lines that parroted the book, but it came off as if they didn't really understand it. That's why I said it seemed shallow. On a side note, I think it is perfectly valid to compare a book to a movie. I get a little frustrated with the recurring statement on this forum "you can't really compare them because they're different." Whether it's Land vs. Dawn, Starship Troopers book vs. movie, or apples vs. oranges. Of course they're different. That's why they can be compared at all. But they're not so different that they have no aspects in common. Land and Dawn are both horror movies. The ST book and movie both try to tell the same story. Apples and oranges are both fruit. If you keep in mind the inherent differences you can form a basis for comparison. At the highest level you can simply ask yourself which did you like more? That's a valid comparison. To try to get a little bit back on topic. I think that a World War Z movie would be great, but not if it has a sucky script. Making a bad adaptation would be worse than waiting. I'm still waiting for an I Am Legend that I'm happy with and the current adaptation has done nothing but prolong that waiting. It'll probably be another 10-15 years before the next incarnation is tried. I'd hate to see World War Z get made and suck because it'll mean a long wait for a second attempt. If the script is floating around and fans think it sucks probably best that it dies.

[laidbackzepfan]

Hey guys, I don't post often but I read all of the posts very regularly. I want to thank everyone for discussing this book. I have never heard of it, so I called up Barnes and Noble and picked it up today. I absolutely love what I have read so far. I am glad that this is not your usual dumb-downed science fiction crap, but a thoughtful, intricate story. If I continue at the rate i'm going, i'll be done this book in a couple days or less. A real page turner. Thanks again!!!

[Neil]

Director is 'Quantum of Solace', Marc Forster. http://www.variety.com/article/VR111...goryid=13&cs=1 http://www.slashfilm.com/2008/11/13/...t-world-war-z/

[bassman]

Now this is what I call good news for the genre. I can't believe they didn't get some music video or commercial director that can make it "hip". Haven't seen Quantum of Solace yet, but I like the dude's work. 'Stay' blew my mind.....

[Neil]

Now this is what I call good news for the genre. I can't believe they didn't get some music video or commercial director that can make it "hip". Haven't seen Quantum of Solace yet, but I like the dude's work. 'Stay' blew my mind..... So, quality script writer and quality directory. Wonder if Hanz Zimmer is available Mind you, maybe there shouldn't be any music/score!!

[blind2d]

Hmm... that would possibly make it more engaging, but on the other hand, it would probably cause the mindless dolts in the audience to fall asleep.

[AcesandEights]

Yup, this is the best news for the genre I've heard in a while. Makes for a very, very happy Friday, for me.

[Publius]

Yep, definitely seems like good news.

[MinionZombie]

Well if that's the case, hopefully that'll mean shamblers. Somebody of Forster's calibre should be able to work with a quality writer to give us a shamblers movie adapted from a book written about shamblers - it's not like they'd really have to invent a lot by themselves, situations and such to allow people to fall victim to the shamblers you know. As for QoS, Campbell (Casino Royale) is a better Bond director than Forster in my opinion. Thank fook, mind you, that it didn't go to some music video tool, or Mc-f*ckin'-G or goodness knows what else.

[Publius]

Well if that's the case, hopefully that'll mean shamblers. Somebody of Forster's calibre should be able to work with a quality writer to give us a shamblers movie adapted from a book written about shamblers - it's not like they'd really have to invent a lot by themselves, situations and such to allow people to fall victim to the shamblers you know. I hope to God you're right! A movie of a book like WWZ with this caliber of support is a huge opportunity, and I'd hate to see it squandered.

[Mutineer]

This is great news ! Forster is a true auteur. Now this is what I call good news for the genre. I can't believe they didn't get some music video or commercial director that can make it "hip". Not digging on Zach I hope ? Snyder is the real deal.

[DawnGirl27]

Very good news, indeed. This can be the most incredible movie, if only it is done right, and well. Pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeease!

[Bub666]

This is awesome news.Hopefully this movie will be good.

[MinionZombie]

Very good news, indeed. This can be the most incredible movie, if only it is done right, and well. Pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeease! Indeed, you'd think with the talent on board, and the quality of the source material, it'd be hard to f*ck up ... but then again, Max Payne the movie is apparently a load of turd compared to the excellent source material. Let's hope for quality - and most importantly - SHAMBLERS.